Phenyl- vs Cyclohexyl-Substitution in Methanol: Implications for the OH Conformation and for Dispersion-Affected Aggregation from Vibrational Spectra in Supersonic Jets

Abstract

The monomers and hydrogen-bonded dimers of benzyl alcohol, cyclohexyl methanol, and 2-methyl-1-propanol are investigated by jet-FTIR spectroscopy, complemented by Raman spectra and quantum chemical calulations, including CCSD(T) corrections. A large variety of London dispersion effects from the interacting carbon cycles is revealed, sometimes adding to and sometimes competing with the alcoholic hydrogen bonds. Conformational (in-)flexibility provides the key for understanding these effects, and this requires accurate predictions of monomer conformational preferences, which are shown to be subtly at variance with experiment even for some triple-zeta MP2 calculations. In some observed dimers, cooperative OH center dot center dot center dot OH center dot center dot center dot pi patterns are sacrificed to optimize sigma-pi dispersion interactions. In other competitive dimers, dispersion interactions are far from maximized, because that would imply a substantial weakening of the hydrogen bond. In the series from methanol dimer to 1-indanol dimer, which this contribution bridges, B3LYP-D3 appears to switch from an overestimation to a slight underestimation of cohesion, but overall it provides a very useful modeling tool for vibrational spectra of systems affected by both hydrogen bonds and London dispersion.