Trophic consistency of supraspecific taxa in belowground invertebrate communities

Abstract

1. Animals that have similar morphological traits are expected to share similar ecological niches. This statement applies to individual animals within a species and thus species often serve as the functional units in ecological studies. Species are further grouped into higher-ranked taxonomic units based on their morphological similarity and thus are also expected to be ecologically similar. On the other hand, theory predicts that strong competition between closely related species can lead to differentiation of ecological niches. Due to a high diversity and limited taxonomic expertise, soil food webs are often resolved using supraspecific taxa such as families, orders or even classes as functional units. 2. Here we for the first time empirically tested the trophic consistency of supraspecific taxa across major lineages of temperate forest soil invertebrates: Annelida, Chelicerata, Myriapoda, Crustacea and Hexapoda. Published data on stable isotope compositions of carbon and nitrogen were used to infer basal resources and trophic level, and explore the relationship between taxonomic and trophic dissimilarity of local populations. 3. Genera and families had normal and unimodal distributions of isotope niches, suggesting that supraspecific taxa are trophically consistent. The isotopic niche of populations across different localities is better predicted by species than by supraspecific taxa. However, within the same genus, the effect of species identity on stable isotope composition of populations was not significant in 92% of cases. The link to basal resources, i.e. plants or detritus, was convergent in different lineages, while trophic levels followed the Brownian motion taxonomic model. Virtually none of the studied taxa showed pronounced trophic niche conservatism within a lineage. 4. Supraspecific taxa are meaningful as functional units in ecological studies, but the consistency varies among taxa and thus the choice of taxonomic resolution depends on the research question; generally, identification of taxa should be more detailed in more diverse taxonomic groups. We compiled a comprehensive list of mean Δ13C and Δ15N values of invertebrate taxa from temperate forest soils allowing to refine soil food-web models when identification to species level is not feasible.